Long Overdue Five Year Farm Bill Still Lingers in Limbo - We'll Follow It With "Accountability Ticker"
iowa Delegation Owns a Big Part of Continuing Farm Bill Failure
469 Days: The number of days that have elapsed without Congress passing a new five year Farm Bill since it expired on September 30, 2023. (Total days as of Sunday, 01/12/2025)
The bold face paragraph you see above is a new “Accountability Ticker” this column is instituting to keep tabs on just how late a new five year Farm Bill is, in the wake of the continued failure of Congress to write a new one since the old one - last written in 2018 - expired.
The legislation is vital for America’s family farmers and other agriculture sectors - but remains un-enacted - over a year and a half after the bill that was already five years old and out of date then - expired.
Meanwhile, Congress - including Iowa’s congressional delegation - pursues the job of writing a new five year farm bill with the urgency of paint drying and the effectiveness of the mythological Greek, Sisyphus, who spent eternity rolling a huge rock up a hill only watch it roll back down once he got to the top, never completing the task.
Though I think Sisyphus may have put more effort into what he was trying to accomplish.
The Farm Bill was last written in 2018. It expired on September 30, 2023. A new one should have been written before the old one expired. It wasn’t. There have been numerous promises to get the bill enacted:
before it expired in 2023;
later in 2023, after it expired;
then early in 2024; For sure!;
well, then mid-2024;
ok, late in the session in 2024; We’re certain of this;
perhaps maybe after the election;
before the 118th Cogress ends in December 2024
Well, for sure right after the new 119th Congress begins in January 2025 - which is where we are now.
A quick check of the website of the House and Senate Ag Committees reveals no press releases announcing any new progress on a new Farm Bill as the new 119th Congress begins. And no committee meetings or hearings are scheduled on the Farm Bill or anything else next week.
They are in a really big rush to get this done, aren’t they?
I don’t know about you, but I wouldn’t go back to a cafe with service this slow and lousy, or that makes so many broken promises to deliver so much as a hamburger to me. Yet, here we are with the Farm Bill, and no metaphorical “hamburger” in sight even yet!
Four of Iowa’s six member congressional delegation serve on the congressional Agriculture Committees: Both U.S. Senators Chuck Grassley (R-IA) and Joni Ernst (R-IA) are on the Senate Ag Committee. and Reps. Zach Nunn (R-3rd IA) and Randy Feenstra (R-4th IA) are on the House Ag Committee.
They are not idle bystanders in this failure of Congress to do its job for farmers by getting a new five year Farm Bill written. They own a big part of that failure.
Each bragged about how important their membership on the Agriculture Committee was for Iowa’s economy and Iowa’s familly farmers when they were named to the panels.
Yet, here we are: Iowa is one of the leading agriculture states in the nation; two thirds of its entire congressional delegation serves on the congressional ag committees; and still a new Farm Bill languishes, the old one long out of date, expired, and a new one gathering dust.
Granted, bragging and sending press releases are both a lot easier to do than passing legislation, but that’s not why any of them were sent to Congress. They were sent there to get things done.
Iowans had a right to expect a lot less talk from Iowa’s Republicans on the Ag Committees about what they “were gonna do” about the Farm Bill and a lot more action to get a new five year Farm Bill written and passed.
That’s not what Iowans got.
What Iowans got was a lot of MAGA-related political tomfoolery aand worse as the Farm Bill languished, unattended.
Senator Grassley has the poorest excuse. Rather than focusing on a new Farm Bill, he pushed MAGA lies about the so-called “Biden crime family,” and the supposed bribes the President and his son, Hunter, supposedly accepted from Burisma, a company in Ukraine. All of it lies. None of it supported by a single scrap or syllable of evidence by Chuck Grassley or anyone else.
There were, however, plenty of politically convenient innuendo and smears from Senator Grassley, the kind that made the MAGA gangs happy and would have made the demagogue, the late former Senator Joe McCarthy (R-WI) proud.
Grassley pushed those lies hard, even when warned by the FBI that the informant, Alexander Smirnov, and his “information” were not reliable.
How do we know it was all lies? The “informant” pushing the smears was charged, pled guilty, and was sentenced this week to six years in prison for lying to the FBI about all of it.
Grassley was a central player in spreading and vouching for Smirnov’s lies - without any credible evidence.
Yet there has not been so much as a mumbled “excuse me” from Senator Grassley, much less an apology from him to the Bidens - or the American people - for his tawdry lies.
Grassley’s pathetic performance in the service of the corrupt political MAGA gang shredded his once, long ago, and proud reputation as a fearless and sharp congressional investigator leaving it in tatters, incinerated in the service of MAGA.
It must have been hard and exhausting work performing that recklessly and incompetently. No wonder Senator Grassley didn’t have time or energy to use his position on the Senate Agriculture Committee to get the Farm Bill across the finish line.
Ernst, for her part, was busy chasing a move up the Senate Republican leadership ladder over the past year, which of course, meant similar partisan fealty to the MAGA gangs and agenda.
Not much time left in the midst of all that for the Farm Bill, either.
Over in the House, most of Nunn’s and Feenstra’s Farm Bill “work” seems to have been spent sending out press releases rather than actually doing the heavy lifting required in Congress to get the bill passed.
It is important not to minimize all this failure.
The Farm Bill is a really big deal for Iowa. It sets the basic policies and ground rules for the nation’s farm and nutrition programs.
Farming is not an industry, or way of life, that easily turns on a dime. Farmers need to plan, often years in advance. That’s what the Farm Bill is supposed to enable, as well as putting a basic safety net for farm operations and rural communities in place to protect from the ravages of market disruption, weather disasters and sudden or cyclical price collapse.
The world has changed since 2018, the last time the current bill - which Congress keeps kicking down the road with extensions of one year or less - was written.
Agriculture itself has changed since 2018.
So why is Congress continuing to saddle farmers with an outdated farm program?
Why are Iowans on the Ag Committees in Congress apparently so willing to let this happen without a sense of urgency to update and write a new five year Farm Bill?
A new Farm Bill needs action. It has needed action for the last two years, and it certainly needs it now. How much longer will Iowans and farmers across the country have to wait?
Senators Grassley? Senator Ernst? Representative Nunn? Representative Feenstra?How much longer does the Iowa delegation’s Farm Bill losing streak continue?
I don’t have those answers, but I can provide a weekly update on how long its been since the old five year Farm Bill expired and how many days a new one is overdue.
That’s what our new weekly Farm Bill “Accountability Ticker” will deliver. Stay tuned.
This column is published as part of the Iowa Writers Collaborative (IWC). This kind of local, independent commentary is an experiment that aims to fill in the gap created by market forces that require many traditional media outlets to cut back the range of what they offer. So far, it’s working, thanks to those of you who are able to become paid subscribers.
We do not accept advertising, so the only source of revenue for our writers is from those who pay to subscribe to individual publications like this one.
The “Barry Piatt on Politics: Behind the Curtains” column keeps a sharp eye on the Iowa congressional delegation, and frequently goes “behind the curtains” to tell you what’s really happening.
If you are able to support this effort with a paid subscription, a free subscription, a “Restack,” or a “Share’ please do so. It makes this column possible. and helps others find us. We even like the “likes” if you see the kind of opinion, commentary and analysis you’d like to see more often.
Iowa Writers’ Collaborative (IWC)
Please explore all of the IWC columns (listed below) and consider a paid or free subscription to several. IWC writers are all professional writers. care deeply about Iowa, and are some the best writers and thinkers in the state. They offer top notch reporting and commentary, as well as a wide range of features. seldom available from traditional media as changing market forces limit what they are able to provide.
Please explore, and try to support five if you can, any way you can.
Both Republican lawmakers and former President Trump appear to benefit politically from legislative dysfunction and a general sense of chaos, including the delayed passage of the farm bill. They seem to prefer disrupting institutional processes rather than engaging in routine, orderly legislation.
Thanks for keeping this issue in the forefront for all of us, Barry. I am not expecting anything good to come from this crew in the next two years on any legislation.